Beyond the Boxes: A Holistic Talent Scorecard for Growth

 People are undeniably more than just two dimensions. While the traditional 9-box grid measures Productivity (important for any organization) and Potential (a clear win for the organization), it often misses crucial nuances. What if that potential isn't aligned with what the organization can offer? What if a highly productive individual doesn't align with the company's core values?

As a basketball fan, I've always appreciated the comprehensive scouting reports on sites like www.nbadraft.net . They provide a clear, multi-faceted picture of a player's capabilities through a detailed scorecard. It's all about individual attributes, not just fitting into a simple box. Look at an example:

When it comes to performance reviews, we often simplify complex realities. Yet, career ladders, which can lead to promotions or performance improvement plans (PIPs), are inherently multi-dimensional. Even with continuous feedback, it's challenging to navigate so many categories and semi-vague descriptions, as seen in examples - see links from this page https://www.swyx.io/career-ladders .

Instead of getting lost in countless categories, I believe in focusing on a few critical dimensions that are often overlooked or under-emphasized in traditional evaluations. By giving individuals a clear "score" across these areas, we create a transparent benchmark they can actively work to "beat" and grow from.

We can't forget about the two vital dimensions from the traditional 9-box:

  • Productivity: The consistent ability to deliver results and meet objectives.

  • Potential: An individual's capacity and desire for future growth and increased responsibility.

But to truly empower individuals and build a thriving organization, we must also add:

  • Alignment with Core Values: How consistently an individual's behaviors and decisions reflect the company's guiding principles.

  • Alignment with Individual Career Goals: The degree to which their current role and available paths align with their personal professional aspirations.

Don't put your team members in a box; give them a scorecard that empowers them to grow, align, and truly excel.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

To Blame or Not to Blame?

As corporate leaders we are taught not to blame , we work hard to create a blameless work environment.  In the Private sector you hear all about mental safety and safe work environment. Yet, as we step into the public world, we ignore all of it, we turn into finger pointing monsters.  I’ve done this with my innocent little kids and I bet you did too.  Have you ever stepped into a room with a broken glass, something has spilled on the floor, and said “WHO DID THIS?”?  That question scares any of us even if not guilty. What if we ask “Is everyone ok?” wait for an answer and then ask “What happened?” When the explosion happened in Beirut , everyone raced to understand the root cause, questioning the “fireworks” storage explosion. Then we felt sorry for the people and city, and at the end we started looking for someone to blame. We have yet to see any reports about inspecting other storage facilities in Lebanon.  Any initiative to build policies and regulation for ...
Read more

A bridge? What to do?

  “Whatever you do, make sure that you keep a relationship going, don’t piss off others.” That is the advice I’ve been getting since my teenage years, for both my personal and professional career.   I lived and continue to live by that advice. It isn’t easy but it sure is worth it to live a life with no enemies and a large network of good people. BUT now I am starting to question the advice. I am not questioning if it is good or bad, but wondering if there is a better approach. In recent years, I also got the advice of engaging with your network, keep these bridges active, it is useless to have them there, take advantage of these relationships. Well, that was a step in the right direction. Don’t burn bridges, but also use them. STILL NOT ENOUGH - Limiting your interactions to your social circle, at work or home, will get you so far. The world is much larger than our circle and if our dream is to grow and expand our options, then we must learn how to connect to the availab...
Read more

Permission to fail

Leaders often grapple with the challenge of finding the right balance between micromanaging and giving their teams the freedom to learn from their mistakes. Early on, my own approach involved identifying risks, discussing mitigation strategies, and, when things went wrong, issuing the dreaded “I told you so.” Over time, I’ve learned the importance of fine-tuning my communication to make it constructive throughout the process, but it’s still a delicate balance. This dynamic is very similar to parenting. As parents, we frequently find it easier to set boundaries for our kids than for our team members. At home, things feel more straightforward—if you drop a plate, it breaks; if you touch something hot, you get burned. Consequences are often immediate and clear-cut. The longest delay might be failing a test due to a lack of studying, but even then, it’s a direct and teachable moment. When my oldest child, who has always been interested in cars, started practicing for their driver’s test, t...
Read more